Italian,
at dusk.
Rooted in Italian tradition, shaped by a modern sensibility. Casa Stellina is built around good food, a thoughtful bar, and a room that always feels alive.
Find a table.
Booking is handled by OpenTable, and your details carry across.
Prefer to speak to someone? Call (516) 943-9111.
What the kitchen is cooking tonight.
Italian classics, thoughtfully prepared, with housemade pastas and a seasonal approach. The menu is designed to feel approachable yet polished, with dishes that are both comforting and elevated.
Aperitivo begins at four.
Well-made cocktails and a wine list that leans Italian, offering a balanced selection to begin the evening. The experience is simple, refined, and meant to be enjoyed at your own pace.
$10 cocktails, two-for-one house wine and a bar menu
Tuesday to Saturday, 4:00 – 6:00 PM. All day Sunday.
A room built for a long dinner.
An inviting, well-appointed space with room to settle in. The restaurant also has 3 private rooms for events and private dining.
Rehearsals. Milestones.
Nights that matter.
3 private room options, semi-private dining and full buy-outs, plus catering for pickup or drop-off. The room changes character when you take it.
The house around the star.
Casa Stellina is a sister to Stellina Ristorante in Oyster Bay, and to the kitchen that started it all, Stella Ristorante in Floral Park, opened by Adriana Milana’s grandparents in 1960.
Stellina means little star. Casa means house. Different room, same hands.
From the Journal.
Notes from the kitchen and the bar.
Sunday is the long one
We open at three and happy hour runs all day. A note on the least hurried service of the week, and why it is our favorite.
Read →
Three rooms, and how to choose one
A birthday, a rehearsal dinner, a company night in December. Two formats, three private rooms, and the questions that decide which is right.
Read →
The veal chop, and the case for the big plate
Sixteen ounces, bone in, breaded, and broiled in the wood-fired oven. When to order the largest thing on the menu, and what to do with the rest of the table.
Read →What guests say after dinner.
4.5 out of 5from 216 Google reviews
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
The steak is amazing!!!! All around great service. Clean location amazing atmosphere. Stop by while I was walking the street and it didn’t disappoint. The servers were attentive. This location stood out to me out of all of them and boy was it meant to be. I would strongly recommend stopping by. Great for groups for a dinner or with a special someone. Everyone here makes you feel at home.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Great food. Pasta is fresh. Service was great!
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Dined here last night for the first time after being a guest at a recent event held here a few weeks ago. I can say I am just as impressed with my dining experience as we all were after the communion party! Great service and the food was even better. Manager and staff very friendly. Would highly recommend for a night out or event a special event! Can’t want to return!
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Last night, we celebrated several retirements from our school, and it was truly a perfect evening. From the very beginning, Mike was an absolute pleasure to work with. He listened carefully to every detail, accommodated all of our requests, including gluten-free meals and desserts, and made the entire planning process feel easy and stress-free. What impressed us most was Mike's presence throughout the evening. He was attentive, flexible, kind, and genuinely invested in making sure everyone had a wonderful experience. His warmth and professionalism made us feel like we were in the best hands. The restaurant was beautiful, warm, and inviting, the food was delicious, and the service was exceptional. Mike and his staff went above and beyond to make our celebration special. We are so grateful for everything they did to help us honor our retirees. It was a night filled with laughter, memories, and appreciation—a night we will always remember. Thank you, Mike and staff, for making it so meaningful.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Clams and mussels as a starter were very good, nice for dipping the fresh foccacia. We had branzino as a main course...fantastic. Dessert pistachio ice cream, delicious. Would order 1 ice cream next time because it's very filling. Overall great experience, highly recommend
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
My partner took me here to get dinner for my birthday. Everything - and I mean everything - was absolutely delicious. We were able to find a fair number of vegetarian dishes. I had a quasi-religious experience with one of their handmade pasta dishes. Although some may find it to be a bit pricey, for a special occassion the food is entirely worth it. The staff was extraordinarily attentive and welcoming. They even threw in a complimentary brownie with ice cream for my birthday, which was just lovely. 5/5★'s, will 100% be dining there again.
Reviews are published on Google, in guests’ own words. Tell us how we did.
Find us on Main Street.
300 Main Street
Farmingdale, NY 11735
New to the village? Here iswhat to know about dining with us.